Should I Repair My Roof or Replace It

If you’re dealing with roofing issues regarding your East Cincinnati home, the first question you have to ask yourself is whether you should repair your roof or replace it. Many factors go into this decision, and it’s not always an easy one to make.

That’s why, here, we’ll discuss factors you need to look into before deciding which is which and we will also go over the pros and cons of repairing your roof vs. replacing it, so that you can make the best decision for your home. Read on!

When Should you Opt to Replace Your Roof?

Complete roof replacement entails removing all existing roofing materials and disposing of them properly before replacing them with brand new plywood cladding, new buckling, and a novel set of shingles.

In most cases, a roof replacement in East Cincinnati might take a few days and be able to price up to $20,000 based on the roof shingles, the installer, and the sizing. Despite the overwhelming chore of replacing it, such may not be required. Replace your roofing after you’ve reached the following milestones.

Leakage and Damage Within The Shingle Compartment

The joists and floorboards of your roofing might decay if they are exposed to moisture on a regular basis. Mold development can also be a result of excessive moisture, putting your health in danger. Look for discoloration, musty odors, or fissures in the woodwork, all of which indicate water damage. Shingles that are curved or broken, as well as granule loss, are other red flags. As soon as you notice a substantial amount of roof leakage, you should get your roof evaluated and replaced for any possible water damage.

It’s already Outdated and is in a Very Poor State

The normal roof lifespan around is somewhere between 20 to 30 years, based on the substance, circumstances, and craftsmanship. If you do possess an old set of shingles or have had destruction from adverse weather through the years, it’s definitely an opportunity to replace it. Replacing parts of broken tiles may only be an interim cure.

Growth of Saggy Structure

If your roof droops or sags, it might be a sign of structural deterioration or an accumulation of moisture that could lead to wood rot. Frost heave, ice, and waste all add some weight to the roofing, forcing it to droop and putting additional strain on the beams and joists, which can lead to structural damage. This is really a warning indication that you need to replace your roof.

Ups and Downs of Replacing Your Roof

The cost of a new roof is significantly higher than the cost of roofing repairs. Here are the advantages and disadvantages of a roof replacement:


  • All roofing issues, even those concealed beneath the shingles, are addressed.
  • Down the road, a new set of roofing can help you set aside funds.
  • It has the potential to improve a home’s curb appeal.
  • It can help save money on utility costs and increase energy efficiency.
  • Replacing it is bound to have a more lengthy life than a repair.


  • You’ll need extra supplies, time, and personnel if you decide to replace your entire roof.
  • It is a more costly undertaking.
  • When compared to a repair, a new roof might take considerably longer to finish.

When Should you Opt to Repair Your Roof?

Roof re-roofing in East Cincinnati may not be necessary if the roof is in good condition, up-to-date, and has suffered just minimal roof damage. Here are the following conditions where you don’t have to replace it right away:

Only Possesses a Minority in The Magnitude of Damage

Small areas of your roofing that have been damaged by weather and need fresh shingles can be simply replaced if it is still in good condition. It’s more expensive to install a steel or clay roofing tile, but far less costly than a complete roof replacement. The main disadvantage of replacing merely a portion of your rooftop is that the new tiles might not even match the existing ones.

If the breach is tiny, localized, and hasn’t produced any water leakage to the joists or rafters, it’s feasible to rectify the problem. You should always get your roof examined before you begin any repair, no matter how minor or extensive, to make sure that the damage to your roof is not too severe.

You Currently Don’t Have The Budget

Roof upgrades are pricey, which may deter some owners who are on a strict budget from making the investment. A repair can set you back hundreds of dollars if you only need minor work when compared to proceeding to replace it. Minor repairs are permissible if your roofing desperately needs renovation, but the rooftop deck is physically solid and updated.

(facebook cover) (18)

Ups and Downs of Roof Repair

In some cases, it may not be the best option to undertake a roof repair operation. In order to assist you in making an informed decision, let us examine the benefits and drawbacks of each alternative. Repairing a roof has its advantages and disadvantages.


  • It is less expensive to fix a roof.
  • When it comes to repairs, it does not take much time at all.
  • Repairs can make your roof last longer.


  • Color matching might become tricky when changing a small number of shingles. It’s possible that these repairs will detract from the curb attractiveness of your roof.
  • More issues might arise if the repair or the craftsmanship is shoddy.
  • It’s a potential way to hide difficulties.

How to Decide on Whether you Have to Repair Your Roof or Replace it?

If you’ve read thus far, you’re undoubtedly aware of the need for a thorough roof inspection in determining the best course of action for your particular circumstance. Through an investigation, you will be able to know whether a roof replacement is necessary or a repair will suffice.

However, inspections might be dangerous for you. If you want to have a free inspection from roof specialists around the area, Mighty Dog Roofing in East Cincinnati will help you assess your roof’s genuine state so that they can recommend and give the best solution for your specific roofing difficulties. Schedule an appointment and get your roof upgraded today!

Meta description: Stuck between deciding on whether you need to repair your roof or just replace it right away? Let this article help you in doing so!

You May Also Like